Month: February 2020

Posted on by

USMLE Step 1 New Pass/Fail Grading-Winners and Losers From A Program Director’s Perspective!

grading

Every year, program directors spend large amounts of time and effort in the application process to select qualified radiology residents. Currently, we rely upon sparse information to ensure we get capable residents. And, one of those pieces of data includes one of a few items that discriminate all applicants equally regardless of institution, nationality, or sort of medical school degree: the USMLE Step 1 examination. But, that stream of information will become even more meager. As some of you may have heard, as of 2022, this USMLE Step 1 examination will become a pass/fail examination. As a result, we lose out on a discriminator that can assess a resident’s ability to pass exams and correlates to passing our radiology core examination. Unfortunately, these changes render the test useless for our purposes.

So, we will need to rely upon other methods to select residents that can pass a radiology board examination. In this case, let’s take this issue on step further. How is the new grading system going to affect applicants? And, who will be the winners and losers? Let me guide you through what I predict will happen once the new grading system for this exam begins.

Winners

Ivy League Medical Graduates/Medical Schools

Since we are losing out on one of the few means of equalizing all applicants, we will have to rely more upon the “name” of the school rather than the individual data points. Therefore, known medical schools will take on higher importance in the application process. Regardless of quality, the system is forcing us to use the institution’s reputation over the quality of the individual’s data.

Poor Test Takers

For those folks with problems passing an examination, this change will help somewhat. You will have one less exam to obsess about your score, now that you only have to pass the test. Of course, you will now need to do well on the Step II examination. And, this test will probably replace the Step I exam as a screening tool for the ERAS application to our specialty. But, it is one less hoop for the average poor exam taker to jump through.

Step II USMLE Examination Review Courses

Now that acing the Step I examination no longer becomes significant, program directors will need to rely on another indicator for test-taking abilities. And, the only one left during the residency will be the Step II examination. So, this will force applicants to take this examination m0re seriously. So, you will probably see more Step II courses sprouting up to help applicants score well on this test.

Losers

Foreign Applicants

As program directors, we like to compare apples to apples when assessing resident applications. And, many times, it is harder to determine the quality of a medical school when it does not adopt the standards of the ACGME. So, we need to rely on other means to assess the residents. Now, we lose out on another data point to do so. Therefore, foreign residents will be the first to lose out in the selection process at the expense of other standardized medical institutions.

Radiology Program Directors

For several reasons, this will hamper our radiology residency selection process. First of all, we are losing out on one of the only examinations that correlate with passing the core exam. Therefore, theoretically, we will be accepting more residents that will not be able to pass a standardized test, the core examination. Second, we will have a smaller pool of applicants from which to choose, now that many of us will require applicants to take the USMLE Step II as our “test-ability discriminator.” Third, we will be more delayed in waiting for Step II exams to come in for the ERAS application. And, finally, we will have one less data point to use in our assessment arsenal.

Step I Pass-Fail Grading: Changing The Playing Field!

Tweaking the testing process always changes the outcomes for those applicants that take them. And, the new grading system for the USMLE Step I is no exception. In the radiology application process, there will be clear winners and losers. Foreign applicants and radiology program directors will get the short end of the stick. Meanwhile, Ivy League applicants and poor test-takers will benefit a bit more. And, to assess applicants, we will become more reliant on Step II USMLE examination. So, these are the main changes that lurk over the horizon. Get ready to change accordingly!

 

 

 

 

 

Posted on by

Things To Not To Do When Ranking A Program Number One

number one

For those of you involved in an NRMP matching process (radiology residency or fellowship), you only have a few more weeks to finalize the rank list. But, the most significant decision is to rank number one. Why? Well, you have around a fifty-fifty chance of getting that spot if you are thinking about putting it down on your rank list, better than any other place. So, how do you make sure that you are clicking the right program when you finalize it all? Well, to sure ensure your sanity and make sure you have the best likelihood of getting this spot, here are some things that you should not do with your number one ranked program.

Don’t Play Mind Games

It’s not worth thinking about whether or not the program wants you badly. That should play no part in the assessment to rank a position as number one. Only, and I mean only, should you list a program first if you want to go there. It would be best if you only took your assessment of the program into the equation. If the program selected you and you didn’t want the program, where does that leave you? In a matching spot that you don’t like, of course!

Don’t Lie

It is unethical to let a program know that you are going to be ranking a program first unless you mean it. Some programs will use this information to rank you higher if they liked you in the first place. (a residency will not change their rankings if they don’t!) Regardless, if for whatever reason, you decide on a different program than the program that you said was your first choice, and then match with another site, forever hold your peace! Radiology is a small world. And, the ramifications of doing this are myriad. Not to say the least, unbeknownst to you, programs may blackball you in the future if you decide you want a job with one of their faculty. You never know!

Don’t Get Too Invested In Your Number One Choice Before You Match There

There is one guarantee in life: that there is no guarantee! Just because you are confident that a program is going to choose you, don’t buy a condo next door. Until it is official, you never know. I know of several students that had bought all the T-shirts of the presumed institution that they will attend, only to find out that they had not matched at the program. Please. Wait until you have the residency has accepted you before telling your colleagues. You don’t want to look like a fool!

Don’t Psyche Yourself Out Of Your Number One Rank

Your number one choice selected you for an interview for a reason. Regardless of how you may feel now, you do have a chance of getting a spot at your first choice. That chance is probably better than you think!

Don’t Forget To Double Check You Number One Choice

Computers and people’s hands are finicky. You can easily click the wrong button and not realize what you have selected. Or, maybe you changed your mind about your first choice and forgot to choose the program on the match list. In either case, check and recheck that list multiple times before you click submit!

Ranking A Program Number One- Don’t Take It Lightly

The matching process is a headache. But, you’ve already made it through seven-eighths of the ordeal. Don’t screw it all up at the last minute. Make sure to dot your i’s and cross your t’s. Ranking your first choice is a big deal. So be careful and remember: many applicants get their first pick!

 

Posted on by

Are You Getting the Outpatient Experience You Need In Your Residency Program?

outpatient experience

Some radiology residency programs throughout the country often claim a great outpatient experience. And others, if you ask, they won’t mention it at all. As an interviewee, you may not think about this segment of radiology. But, as a practicing radiologist, this is where you will spend a good chunk of your time.

So, what are the different sorts of outpatient experiences? And, is this outpatient experience even critical to your training? Or, is it something that you can forego because the hospital covers it? The bottom line, are you getting the outpatient time that you need?

Let’s investigate the world of outpatient radiology and what it all means for the typical radiology resident. To do so, I am going to discuss why it is critical to your training. Then, I will split the categories out outpatient imaging into those that you might encounter. And finally, I will talk about what you genuinely need in radiology residency to make your outpatient experience complete.

Why Is Outpatient Imaging So Important?

They say that about 90 percent of radiologists go into private practice (me included!), and the other 10 percent become hospital academics. And, a large swath of those 90 percent practices some form of outpatient imaging. Moreover, the imaging mix differs in outpatient imaging compared to the standard hospital menu of cases. So, if you want to simulate the real practice of radiology, you need some form of outpatient experience.

Three Different Types Of Outpatient Environments

Hospital Outpatient

Almost all hospitals have nonemergent patients that will show up to receive their imaging. The extent can vary from hospital to hospital depending on the location, patient mix, etc. However, the sort of patient that shows up for nonemergent imaging at a hospital tends to differ from the standard clinic patient that wants imaging. These studies often are more complex. And, they show up to the hospital either because they have some complicating issue that prevents them from getting outpatient center imaging (asthma, contrast reaction, etc.) Or, they may have an appointment at the hospital and may as well get their studies. Finally, less likely, a patient will show up here because he wants to go to a hospital rather than an imaging center.

Regardless, these outpatients will less likely have complaints like osteoarthritis or a superficial lump on the back. Instead, the patients will overall have more complex and involved issues. So, your mix of patients will not be the same.

Hospital Owned Outpatient Center

This experience is a hybrid between private practice imaging and the outpatient hospital experience. Here, you will get complex referrals from a hospital center. But, you will also receive the more typical outpatient type of studies. When you sit down and read, you will find a mix of patients with widely varying difficulty levels of cases.

Private Practice Outpatient

And most likely, private practice is what you think of as the “pure” outpatient experience. Here you get referrals almost exclusively from local doctors. Or, you will get patients who come in independently to receive screening tests like mammograms. Cases tend to be more one complaint sort of issues with more “normals.”

How You Might Experience Outpatient Radiology

Sampling

Depending on how the residency arranges your outpatient experience, you may be an occasional observer. Perhaps, the attendings dictate the outpatient cases because they get paid for them. And, you get to watch them interpret the studies. Or, it may be a random sampling as you are reading hospital outpatients. In either case, this is not the immersive type of outpatient experience.

Immersive

Here, you will be primarily interpreting outpatient cases and having your attendings sign off on them. It is much more similar to the daily workflow you might encounter in any given private practice. You will have a more similar experience as an outpatient private practice radiologist.

What Is The Best Outpatient Experience?

Well, as usual, the answer depends. Though, the key to becoming an excellent radiologist, in general, is to have varied experiences across the board. It is possible to have too much outpatient radiology at the expense of inpatient imaging, especially if you want to become a hardcore academic. So, you need to ask yourself, am I getting a broad enough experience concerning all the other segments of radiology training for my interests?

Nevertheless, I would recommend searching for a program that gives you the capability of reading and interpreting all sorts of “simple” and complex outpatient cases. And, I also believe that immersive experience is better. Why? Well, it allows you to get a feel for private outpatient practice. And, it will enable you to make a more informed choice of practice situations when you ultimately decide to settle on a final path.

Are You Getting What You Need To Become An Excellent Radiologist?

Having all the ingredients available for you to get the training you need to become a radiologist, well, that is the main point of residency. So, if you are in a situation that does not give you the right mix outpatients, look into ways that you can get the appropriate outpatient experience. Take some time and effort on your part to create a custom rotation. Or, push your faculty to allow you to get the proper exposure. In any case, make sure not to skip out on this subsegment of radiology. Without this experience, you will not be the consummate well-trained radiologist you want to be!

 

Posted on by

What Do Radiology Program Directors Really Want From Their Residents? The Perfect Resident Triad!

perfect resident triad

This year, applicants have asked the following question more than ever before, “What do I look for in a radiology resident?” And I will answer this question with what I like to call “the perfect resident triad.” But first, I thought it would be interesting to discuss why I believe this question has become more common coming from medical students.

The Psychology Behind The Question, “What Do Radiology Program Directors Really Want From Their Residents?”

On the surface, some folks may say I am putting too much thought into why applicants may be asking this question. But, I believe this question says something about medical students applying to radiology. There is more to it than meets the eye.

First, I believe this question reflects current medical student cultural differences. Distinct from generations past, this question requires applicants to worry more about goals and expectations than any class before. And I think this difference is a function of what today’s educational system has demanded of all these students.

Moreover, I believe that schools have gone “ga-ga” with grading. From my own experience with kids, students today are continually bombarded with grades and tests, more so than I had ever experienced. In essence, the increased frequency of this question with the implied inherent message of “how do you evaluate me?” makes a lot of sense given today’s student culture environment.

Regardless of all the hidden meanings behind the question (that could be a whole psychological blog in itself!), I figured this would be a great forum to provide you an associate program director’s perspective and answer to this common question. And, maybe it will help you to figure out how to become a better radiology applicant and resident. So, here’s a summary of the perfect resident triad, the three characteristics that I want from incoming residents!

The Perfect Resident Triad

Academic Abilities

First and foremost, we need to know that a resident can make it through the radiology residency program. And, nowadays, unfortunately, the best piece of evidence that allows us to assess if a resident can pass the boards is the USMLE Step I. Studies have correlated excellent performance on this examination with the core examination, So, we need to take this data point seriously. To do so, we have made a cutoff score that will lessen the chance of having residents fail the exam.

Second, we need to see that you have done well in medical school. Our best assessment of this comes from the Dean’s letter. This document tends to be the only one that will say anything negative about the applicant. Therefore, we need to use it as a means of distinguishing resident academic qualifications. Also, from our experience, this measure correlates well with how much a resident will study during residency. And, radiology residents need to read a lot!

Personality

Although you might not think personality should matter much in a radiology resident, nothing could be further from the truth. Faculty members can sit with a radiology resident for hours at a time. The ultimate burden that a faculty member needs would be to dread that a particular resident is going to be there on any given day. Additionally, program directors do not want a “rabble-rouser” that will create problems every other day for her fellow residents.

The bottom line is, personality counts. And, to assess personality, there are only a few bits of information that we can use, interviews, and the Dean’s Letter. We rely on our interviews to make sure that the applicant responds reasonably to a conversation with questions. And, we utilize the Dean’s Letter to look for patterns of behavior that may cause our lives to be miserable!

Independence

Finally, we do not want to have to tell our residents what to do at every given moment. Sometimes, you have to take the bull by the horns. So, we expect not to have to tell them to get involved with as many procedures and cases as possible. And, we don’t want to be on top of them all the time to make sure that they find a research project. And so on. Residents are adults, and we expect them to act like mature learners that can take charge of their education.

We assess this characteristic based on the interview, previous research, and academic performance. Although not perfect assessment tools for this trait, they do provide us with some quality information.

What Do Program Directors Want?

So, that’s what I want from my residents and what I believe most program directors would wish: the “perfect resident triad”: To summarize, we want the following: 1. A team member that does well academically. 2. A resident with a personality with which we can work. 3. And, someone who maintains a bit of an independent streak. If you are that sort of medical student or resident now, you will be an invaluable member of any radiology residency team. Come aboard!