Year: 2017

Posted on by — 1 Comment

Radiology Call- A Rite of Passage

call

Every year around the beginning of July, I see some of the most haunted radiology resident faces, right around 10:00 pm, just after the attending evening shift ends and the resident night shift begins. It is almost always a second-year radiology resident who happens to be starting their first night of call. What if I miss something important? What if I say something stupid? Will I be able to handle the intensity? Will I fall asleep? And most importantly, will I kill someone?

The resident only unlocks the answers to these burning questions on the first night. Only after this event does the resident and the program director know whether or not they can handle the burdens of a radiologist. Everything in the first year leads to this point: the precall quiz, the intense reading, the conferences, and the studying. It’s crunch time.

Just before the first night of the dreaded call, my famous last words are: you begin the night as a kid, and you will end the night as an adult. Why do I say that? Because I think the truth lies embedded in that statement. You can never become a full-fledged radiologist until you are responsible for independently making patient decisions. It’s like all those ancient traditions in all religions/cultures, like hunting that first wild boar, the confirmation, the bar mitzvah, etc. The residency now allows you to function as an independent, freethinking human being who can make decisions on your own. Until then, you are merely an observer, not an active participant.

Since taking night coverage is such an intense and essential experience, you must follow certain tenets to make it valuable and safe. I will enumerate eight simple golden rules of call I wish I had known before beginning those fated first nights to come. I urge that you follow all of them to enrich your education safely. Do not stir the wrath of your fellow staff members and program directors in the morning by breaching these rules!

Look at every film with these primary thoughts- what will kill the patient, and what is common?

I can guarantee that if you look at every film with these thoughts at the forefront of your brain and have done the prerequisite work to get to call, you will not severely harm any of your patients. When you look at a chest film, always think pneumothorax. If you see a female pelvic ultrasound, always think ruptured ectopic. When you look at a CT scan in a patient with right lower quadrant pain, always think of acute appendicitis. And so forth. Thinking about badness will prevent undiscovered horribleness in the morning.

Likewise, when you look at films, always think about the most common diagnoses first, and you will be right much more often than wrong. For instance: Opacity on a chest film- pneumonia, not Hampton’s hump. Restricted diffusion on a brain MRI- infarct, not ependymoma. Abnormality on a GI bleeding scan, think primary GI bleed, not Meckel’s diverticulum with bleeding gastric remnant. I can guarantee your attending faculty will look at you funny if you come up with too many zebras!

Always, always, always maintain your search pattern in every study.

In the radiology world, one of the main ways to miss something is not to look for it. Sometimes in the middle of the night, the pressure will seem impossible, and you must deliver an answer at that second. Perhaps, a team of 4 angry surgeons comes down and asks, “What is going on with the film?” and needs to know now! Or, an inpatient resident shoves a chest film in front of your face and says, “What’s going on here?” Maybe, the emergency medicine doctor calls incessantly to get a read on that CT chest for dissection.

In each of these cases, I don’t care how emergent and immediate they need the answer, always step back and go through your search pattern. Everyone makes this cardinal error at one time or another. Avoid it! Step back and say give me a moment. Go through each organ or region rigorously. You will look much less stupid than blurting a diagnosis/finding out only later to realize it was wrong because you haven’t thoroughly analyzed the study. One of the worst feelings is finding the doctor who just left your department with the wrong answer, who is getting ready to begin an unnecessary surgery on a patient, or a doctor who will discharge a patient that needs to stay in the hospital!!

If there is no harm to the patient, it is easier to do the study than to fight it.

Most residents take a while to learn this one piece of sage advice. At nighttime, you will have limited time for everything. Interruptions will pull you in fourteen different directions at once. You will receive calls from the emergency department, the floors, the surgeons, etc. And often, these events tend to happen all at once. So, I urge you that if a study is reasonable, do it.

You will spend more time and energy preventing a study from getting done than just completing it. Of course, if it significantly harms a patient, then obviously avoid it. But that is the exception rather than the rule. That fluoroscopy study to rule out a foreign body that you try to block after the resident ordered it: I can guarantee it will come back hours later when you are either exhausted or have lots of things going on at once. So, just do the study!!!

Don’t let your temper get the best of you. You will hear about it in the morning!

Every resident encounters a curt gynecologist, a rude surgeon, a loud, demanding resident, and so on at some point. You are likely going to be grumpy and tired as well. It may seem like a good idea to talk back to that person similarly rudely and unprofessionally. Or, you may want to take a swing at one of these annoying chaps. But don’t do it. One of the most common complaints at nighttime is a letter written by an attending or a resident colleague saying this radiology resident was unprofessional and handled the situation poorly under pressure. This complaint will come regardless of whether the radiology resident is right or wrong. And often, it will stay in the resident’s file/record. Don’t let that be you!!!

Residents best handle resident matters. Attending matters are best handled by attendings.

At nighttime, many times, a clinician may need an attending radiologist. So, make sure you don’t go in over your head. Call your attending when necessary. The worst thing you can do in the morning is to perform a procedure that your attending should have done or make a phone call that really should have been handled by your attending, only to find out that the wrong thing happened. It will become the talk of the town in the department, not in a good way. An attending should always read a brain scan because of litigation issues. A faculty radiologist should always be present for an intussusception reduction. And so on. Don’t go over your head!

On the other hand, if you have a resident issue at nighttime, try to handle it yourself. If the Emergency Department asks you whether to give the contrast, make that decision. If a resident comes down to ask a question, answer it. You will only learn how to make the more minor decisions by playing the role of a radiology resident.

Ask for help if you can’t handle something at nighttime.

Sometimes, the job may be too much to bear for one person. (A disaster happened with every patient getting a total body CT scan) Perhaps, it is a question that an expert needs to answer. (A subtle abnormality on an emergent Neuro CTA) And, other times, administrative issues that only your chair or program director can handle. (The MRI broke – should we recommend sending patients to another hospital?) If such problems arise at nighttime, make sure to call the appropriate channels going from lowest to highest in command. If it is a patient question that you are not sure about, ask your chief resident. Then, if they can’t answer the question, you may want to ask the assigned attending on-call. And, up the chain, it goes.

If you decide to handle everything yourself and it is inappropriate for your level, you can almost be sure that repercussions will occur in the morning. So please, ask for help when it is needed and appropriate!!

Always answer your beeper/phone/pager.

Occasionally, we hear about a resident sleeping and not answering their pager at nighttime. Unfortunately, those residents will often get written up in the morning for lack of timely dictation. So, jack up the sound on your beeper/phone/pager. And, take all calls!!!

Look at the films. Don’t rely on the ER or Nighthawk reads.

Being on call is the time to remove the umbilical cord and develop independence from your mentors/attendings. So, do not repeat a dictation or reading that is already present. You should do everything de novo/from scratch, although you should look at their reads afterward. It also seems silly when the resident’s dictation matches the Nighthawk dictation verbatim and hints that the resident may not have looked at the films. When I am on in the morning, I appreciate the extra set of eyes that a resident used to check the cases even though others have looked at the study. And, it is not infrequent that our residents catch essential findings that the nighthawk didn’t notice. So please, do your independent reads/dictations!!!

Summary statement

Call is a challenging but integral part of raising a radiology resident right. It is a time of trials and tribulations. You can and will make it through this harrowing trial if you follow the golden rules. Good luck!

——————————————————-

Need some help with what you need to learn before taking call? Check out the following books on Amazon!

Emergency Radiology Case Review Series

Core Radiology

 

———————————————————-

This article is featured on auntminnie.com!!! Click here for the Aunt Minnie version of the article. 

 

Posted on by

Transferring From Another Specialty to Radiology: Will I Be Competitive?

radiology

Question:

Dear Barry,

I will be finishing my categorical surgery intern year. I have decided to reapply this year for radiology, with a strong interest in IR. I am aware of the competitiveness of IR and DR in general. I am leaving in good standing. Also, I have good scores and achieved AOA. My radiology mentors in my hospital have encouraged me and feel I am competitive. I don’t have any published research, but I am working on projects. In terms of gauging my competitiveness and having realistic goals, how may I improve my application before September 2017?

———————-

Answer:

Get To Know The Radiology Program Director

In the past several years, several surgical interns have transferred to our department. Both residents came to speak to me about their interests while they were surgical residents (one was a SOAP match candidate, and the other stopped during the year to ask about interviews). I think speaking to the program directors increased their chances of getting into our program. It shows initiative! So, if I were in your shoes, one of the first things I would do would be to get to know the program director for radiology if there is a radiology training program in your hospital.

Also, sometimes spots can open up before the year begins, and showing interest in the radiology program can’t hurt. Therefore, it would make sense to talk to the program director about applications for this year. The biggest problem is that you probably will have to wait another year to secure a spot in a radiology residency program since applications are not for 2018-2019 but for 2019-2020. But you never know; a position can open up for the 2018-2019 R1 year.

Finally, it would allow you to get a feel for the quality of your application at your institution. The program directors will usually have insight into your chances of admission.

Get on The Radiology Bandwagon Now

If you have the fortitude to go through another surgical year and wait for a 2019-2020 spot after interviewing this year in the regular match, that would be the most likely way to secure a radiology spot. As you said, if you are a categorical surgical resident, you will likely be a competitive applicant for a radiology residency (even though the specialties of radiology and DR/IR have been getting slightly more competitive over the past year or two). Nevertheless, I would certainly get on the application bandwagon now because if you wait another year, you are less likely to be able to get government funding for a radiology resident spot. You snooze, you lose!!!

Is No Radiology Research An Issue?

Regarding research, it certainly can’t hurt to have completed a project or two. If you are interested in academic radiology, that will add to your application. In a clinical program, it probably doesn’t matter as much. In either case, most residency programs do not require research before entering. But, it does confirm interest in our specialty. Regardless of whether you have completed a research project, I think most program directors (especially IR/DR PDs) like to take surgical residents who have performed well at their institution and demonstrate an interest in radiology. Surgical residents who serve well can handle stress!!!

Make Sure to Apply To The Correct Programs

Also, since you are interested in IR, I would send out applications to residencies that are DR programs with an ESIR program and the new DR/IR program. Applying to both programs maximizes the probability of getting into a residency that allows you to complete IR without having to do a 2-year independent fellowship.

Let me know if you have any other questions.

Barry

 

 

 

Posted on by — 13 Comments

How to Make a Good Impression as a First Year Radiology Resident

impression

It may be your first day, your first month, or maybe you started residency several months ago. Perhaps, you want to make that great first impression on your program director. Or, maybe things are not going as well as you might have liked during your first year. Having worked with numerous first-year residents rotating in our residency and having completed a full four years of residency, I have learned the ingredients you need to become a great first-year resident. As a former resident, I wish I had a list of tips on how to start my radiology resident experience on the best footing possible.

Well, now it’s here. I have a list of 12 ways to improve your radiology residency experience starting in the first year of your diagnostic radiology residency program. Also, I will give you examples of what not to do (these scenarios are real!). Then, I will explain how to make the best of each piece of advice. To all- ENJOY AND HEED THIS ADVICE!!!

Be Enthusiastic

On your first day of radiology residency, you walk into the reading room for the first time, and you are nervous and hesitant. You begin to yawn, mouth wide open. An attending sits in the corner about to read films. You slink back and worm your way into a corner. You don’t introduce yourself for fear of disturbing the attending radiologist. Instead, you start talking to your resident colleagues. Is that a way to start your career? By all means, NO!!!!

My words of advice:

Always make sure to put on your best face forward toward your staff. What does that mean? Well, it’s pretty much common sense. Always introduce yourself. Always ask how you can help. And, always volunteer to participate in a readout or procedure. You have only one chance to learn the things you need to know before practicing as an attending, and that way is RADIOLOGY RESIDENCY. Make it the best learning experience you can, and that involves going that extra mile to show your enthusiasm/interest.

Be On-Time

You wander into the reading room, and it’s 10 AM. When you see your attending radiologist reading out films, he pauses for a moment. You decide to say, “When can we start reading out together?” The attending looks at you with a confused quizzical face. Was I supposed to have a resident today?

My words of advice:

When you arrive in the morning, always let your attending know that you are today’s resident. If you have to step out for a few moments, let him know that you need to leave. It is a sign of respect to let your attending see that you are going to be around to help out, learn, dictate, and ask questions. It will go a long way to establishing a rapport between yourself and your residency staff!

Be Nice to Everyone

It’s your first day, and you walk into the residency coordinator’s office. You sit in her chair, never having seen or met her. And then, you start playing games on her computer. The coordinator walks into the office and stares at you and is thinking: who the heck is this guy?

My words of advice:

Make sure when you are beginning that you are kind to everyone!!! I don’t care if it is the residency coordinator, janitor, technologist, attending, senior resident, or nurse. We are all part of the same team. Moreover, we always hear about our resident’s behavior, good or bad. As residency director, we receive 360-degree evaluations, reviews of the residents from potentially all these sources, and more. I can tell you that if you want to destroy your reputation as a resident, the worst thing you can do is misbehave with your team members, especially the residency coordinator!!!!

Dress Appropriately

You are upstairs on the floors in a t-shirt and ripped jeans. Your ID badge sits in your back pocket with the list of patients to consent. In your morning haze, you stumble up to the door of the 3rd patient with informed consent in hand. You introduce yourself to the patient, and she gives you that look- who are you really, and what are you doing here? You go through your pat explanation of the procedure, the risks, and the alternatives. The patient warily signs the consent form. Great! The last consent of the morning.

Later that afternoon, the program director calls you into the office. It turns out, the patient was the wife of a hospital executive and called the emergency hotline. The program director now has two complaints about this resident, one from the patient’s husband and another from the doctor in the hallway. Both are furious because they did not know who you were and felt uncomfortable confronting you. The program director states, “Go home and change immediately!”

My words of advice:

Always make sure you look and play the part of a physician. Some patients and physicians are easily offended by an inappropriate appearance/uniform. In our world, radiology is a service-oriented profession. Furthermore, appearances fortunately or unfortunately lend credence to your skills, personality, and the department. Please make sure to represent your department in the best light!

Play the Role of An Attending From Day One- Take Responsibility for Your Patients and Department

You roll on into the nuclear medicine department and arrive at the department early. Briefly, you look at the list of patients in the computer. A bone scan and a gallium scan lies waiting as unread. You think to yourself, I know those topics well. I also know it would be much more productive to read a nuclear medicine book on a new subject. As you are waiting for your attending to arrive, you pull out your text and learn about nuclear medicine. The attending walks through the door a few minutes after you started to read and says, “Have you looked at the cases from last night?” You reply, “I was hoping to get my reading done for the day. Didn’t get a chance to look at the cases.”

My words of advice:

When you are on any service, good learners become great radiologists by reading lots of cases. You may know a given topic well, but you can only learn normal from abnormal by reading thousands of cases in different contexts. Unfortunately, you cannot learn this from merely reading a book. The only way to get that experience is to look at lots of cases every day. Take an active role as if you are an “attending.” Radiology is not a spectator sport!

Be Knowledgeable

You are in the second week of your first CT rotation. So, you sit down with the CT attending to go over the day’s work. The attending goes through each of the cases slowly. Finally, she happens upon an abdominal CT scan. You stare at the images, and she asks you about an ovoid cystic density structure just inferior to the liver. You blurt out, oh, that’s easy. It’s an aorta!!! Your attending begins to shake her head slowly and becomes silent. She doesn’t say much for the rest of the day.

My words of advice:

There’s an old radiology adage. The difference between a bad, OK, good, and great radiology resident is the amount you read every night. A bad resident doesn’t read. An OK resident reads 1 hour a night. A good resident reads 2 hours a night. And, a great radiology resident reads 3 hours a night. Don’t be that bad radiology resident! When you start, I encourage you to read a lot, especially emphasizing the basics and anatomy!

Read a Lot, but Make Sure to Study the Images

It is your first day on the new chest film rotation. You have just finished reading an entire textbook on chest radiology. As you start looking at the cases with your attending, you figure that you will try to impress him with your in-depth knowledge of the findings associated with sarcoidosis. So, you start going through a small presentation about your newfound knowledge based on the textual information. After your serenade, he begins to look at the first few cases of the day. Then, he pauses as he starts on the third case of the day.

He asks, “What do you think about this chest film in front of you?” You stay silent as you search the film up and down, left and right. Nothing seems to register as abnormal ton the film. Your attending points out a significant opacity obliterating the vessels behind the heart and obscuring the left hemidiaphragm. He then asks, “Where is the opacity located?” You realize that you have read tons of information on pneumonia but never looked at the pictures. Uh oh! You cannot identify the location based on a mental reference point. Your heart sinks as you realize you have more reading to do…

My words of advice:

Reading a radiology text differs dramatically from reading an internal medicine book, a novel, or other sorts of written information. The most important features of a radiology textbook are usually the pictures and captions below the pictures. So, it behooves the resident to concentrate on these films, often more than the text itself. Of course, you need to understand and remember the disease entities, but radiology is most often about the images!

If a Radiology Attending Asks You a Question, Always Look Up the Answer

So, it’s the end of the day, and you are sitting with your favorite attending. For the few days that you have worked with her, she has a habit of teaching interesting topics while taking cases. It feels like you just read an entire book without even touching a page. She enthusiastically asks you a question about a patient with breast cancer. She says, “I wonder what a sclerotic metastasis would look like on a PET-FDG scan? Maybe you can look it up, and we will go over it tomorrow.”

You go home exhausted and fall asleep slumped over your computer, without even getting a chance to read a word about the topic. You get up in the morning and realize you are running late. Hurriedly, you grab your stuff and arrive barely on time. Sweating profusely, you run into the reading room. Your attending almost sits down at her workstation. And she says, “Did you look that topic up for me?” Unfortunately, you don’t have a satisfactory answer. For the rest of the day and weeks afterward, she barely spends time on her cases with you. You’ve lost many opportunities to learn with your mentor.

My words of advice:

You sow what you reap! When someone, specifically a radiology attending, takes the time out of the day to teach. And, she goes over cases with you out of his/her own free will, it is essential to pay back that person with attention, diligence, and care. By under-appreciating the attending’s time, you change the willingness of a teacher to teach. Remember, most hospitals do not pay radiologists stipends for their time with their residents. Teaching emanates from the goodwill of the staff!

Always get a good history

It is late in the day, and you are about to read the last hepatobiliary scan of the day. But you have to do it quickly because you need to get home to your family. Instead of entering into the electronic health records, you promptly peruse the one-word order on the top of the dictation page. It says pain. So you start reading and dictating the case promptly for the attending with that one-word history. In a few minutes, you finish the dictation.

You walk back to the reading room and begin to go over the case with your attending. Subsequently, he opens the case, looks at your history/dictation, and begins to look at it as the surgical team walks by to get the radiologist’s interpretation. The surgeon asks, “What do you think?” The radiologist says, “With a history of pain, it looks like the gallbladder fills nicely without findings suggesting cholecystitis.” The surgeon responds curtly, “We just took out the gallbladder!!”

My words of advice:

Always take the time to get a great history. As a resident, you should take the time to gather all the information. Without a good history, trust me, you will get burned. So, avoid the inevitable, take your time, and always get all the necessary information!!!

Establish a search pattern for all modalities

The day’s attending sends you out of the room to read a new CT scan of the abdomen. The patient has right lower quadrant pain, and the emergency doctor wants you to rule out appendicitis. So you look through the CT scan quickly and ramble into the Dictaphone about the case. Your eyes move here and there without any specific pattern. Finally, you see some terminal ileum wall thickening and put in your impression- findings suspicious for terminal ileitis/inflammatory bowel disease. Happily, you trot back to your radiology attending to go over the case. Within 10 seconds, your attending says, “You missed the 4 mm obstructive stone in the right ureter!”

My words of advice:

Believe it or not, almost every experienced radiologist has a rigorous search pattern and mental checklist in every case. With this checklist, they don’t miss any findings that may be relevant to patient care. You might not know they have a search pattern/checklist because they have been doing it for so long. And, they rapidly read the cases. But, I can guarantee you will miss plenty of significant findings if you do not go through an organized approach to looking at a film. It happens all the time!!!

Always check for priors

The radiology attending just left the service for the day. You are now on call for the night. The emergency department continues to call the nuclear medicine department every 10 minutes to get the result. Annoying, isn’t it? It is time to give a STAT interpretation of a pulmonary V/Q scan. So, you look at the scan and the associated chest film. And, you see three large mismatches without corresponding findings on the chest film. You call the ER and tell them the scan is positive for pulmonary embolus. You feel good because you think you made the right call for sure.

The next morning at the readout, your attending starts to look at the case. He notices that you didn’t compare to the prior scan. It seems the same. His interpretation- no findings to suggest new pulmonary embolus. He says, “Call the ER right now to make sure the patient doesn’t get more anticoagulants.” You feel like an idiot for missing the correct diagnosis!

My words of advice:

I can’t emphasize enough how important it is to compare priors. Priors will bail you out many times. And, comparing with them makes the difference between shoddy and outstanding patient care. If you want to become a resident star, always make a concerted effort to check for prior studies!

Learn about things that can kill a patient or are common first. Zebras can usually stay at the zoo!

You are taking your first independent call and start to look at your first ultrasound of the evening. It is a 2-year-old pediatric patient with right lower quadrant pain. Looking through the ultrasound images, you see a target like structure in the right upper quadrant. You recently read a large text and saw a case of Henoch Schonlein Purpura affecting the bowel. It happened to look just like it. Your differential reads Bowel thickening from Henoch Schonlein Purpura before anything else. Ten minutes later, the pediatric surgery team trots up the stairs toward your workstation and says, “What are you talking about? We were looking for a large bowel intussusception!”

My words of advice:

Stick to the most common two or three items within the differential diagnosis. You will often be right more than not. As I said, zebras can usually stay at the zoo!!

Making A Good Impression

I’m sure almost all of you want to make your best impression on the staff that you are going to work with for four years. One or two mistakes toward the beginning of your stay can make your life very difficult for the rest of your radiology training. Unfortunately, it is effortless to leave the wrong impression on the staff, but it is harder to correct. To avoid these blunders, I highly recommend you follow these rules. Don’t be the brunt of your residency’s jokes!


Posted on by — 1 Comment

Is The New DR-NM Pathway Worthwhile?

DR-NM pathway

Message For The Director
Hi,
Can you kindly comment on the ABR/ABNM 16-month dual pathway? Is it worth it? Can one get a job without another extra year of fellowship?

Interested Resident

 

 

 

 

 

I would love to talk about the DR-NM pathway. I am an ABR and ABNM certified radiologist, so I am interested in this matter.

Reasons To Not Participate In DR-NM Pathway

If you are going into the DR-NM pathway, you may find a job after the 16-month program during your residency. However, for most people, I would probably opt for the more traditional route for several reasons. First, you will have much less training in general radiology. For most radiologists coming out of residency, you want to maximize your experiences in general radiology so that you feel comfortable in most modalities. You are replacing 12 months of general radiology with almost exclusively nucs. If you have less general radiology, you are less likely to be comfortable with modalities other than nuclear medicine when you work as an attending in general practice. Most radiology residents work for private practices, with some general radiology.

Second, it may be slightly less desirable for most private practice employers to hire someone with less “radiology” experience. Since this DR/NM pathway is so new and there is less general radiology training, employers may recognize this pathway as a second tier.

And finally, you are pigeonholing yourself into nuclear medicine from the beginning. Most programs will want to know that you will complete the DR/NM program as early as possible (perhaps even from day one of residency!) since scheduling mandates that you need a specific set of rotations. Unfortunately, most trainees have no idea what they want to do at the start of residency.

One Reason To Participate In DR-NM Pathway

So, who would be suitable for this program? The individual that has known for a very long time that they want to specifically subspecialize in the nuclear medicine field. Also, this person should be interested in a primarily academic job (I think that would be the one area where employers would find candidates completing this pathway most enticing).

Final Thought

I’m not quite sure where you stand. However, I would generally recommend the standard one-year nuclear medicine fellowship for most trainees.

I hope that helps!

Director1

 

Click here for more information on the DR/NM program.

  

 

 

Posted on by — 2 Comments

What To Look For In A Radiology Residency?

residency

No perfect radiology residency program exists for radiology residency applicants, and no one size fits all. Each candidate has their own needs, wants, and learning style. And each program has its positives and negatives. Therefore, each applicant should strive to match with the appropriate residency. In doing so, the positives of the program should fit well with the applicant’s needs. And, the negatives should be minor and not detract from the overall radiology resident experience.

My goal for today is to discuss the essential ingredients for choosing a radiology residency. Most online overviews do not address many of these crucial factors to look for in a radiology residency program. So, I thought it was critical to include them. Included in my discussion will be of the highest importance to most minor importance: residency culture/hierarchy, location/proximity to family/friends, intimate insider knowledge of a program, rotations/equipment/procedure volume, university vs. community programs, private vs. academic run departments, graduating resident fellowships, conferences, research, mentorship programs, and board passage rates.

In the end, the overall residency experience will allow you to become a great radiologist. So, I will put it all together at the conclusion to help you to make a final decision. To do this, I have assigned an individual point score for each factor. It would help if you recorded for each residency you are considering for ranking. In the end, add up the points. And then, compare to the other residencies on your rank list. When you finish, rank each accordingly.

Residency culture (5 points)

Residency culture is probably one of the most critical factors to think about when choosing a residency. However, it is also one of the most difficult to define. The difference between happiness and misery in a program first and foremost often lies with the colleagues that you have. No matter how excellent the overall “experiences” of a residency program, you will not want to come to work if you hate the people you work with. On the other hand, if the residency is marginal, but the people you work with are fantastic, the four years of residency will not be so bad.

What To Look For

The problem with using this factor for choosing a residency is that it is a moving target. From year to year, residencies accept new residents, and old ones leave. So, the residency culture today may not be present tomorrow. However, the attending, technologist, and coordinator support structures of the residency often remain relatively similar. So, it would help if you got to know the residents and the leaders and purveyors of the program.

In addition to getting a sense of the “happiness” of the residents, you should determine the residency leadership style. Some programs prescribe processes for everything that happens in the program. Other programs have a more laissez-faire attitude. Some programs have one or two leaders at the top that act as “benevolent dictators.” Others have each of the attendings with equal say over residency issues.

No one structure is “correct.”. If you are the type of person that needs a well-defined structure, the hierarchical culture would fit better. On the other hand, if you like to create your path and define your schedule, you may prefer a program with an equal footing.

Location and Proximity to Friends/Relatives (4 points)

Over my years as an associate program director, I have found how important it is for residents to have a social outlet. Although not a “resident related experience” per se, this factor can be just as important. Being near loved ones can make the difference between a terrible residency experience and a great one. A support structure can be just as crucial as the residency program itself. I find that the best residents have a healthy support structure outside of residency. Therefore, the location and proximity to loved ones can be essential factors, just as the residency quality. For instance, who would want to be in Manhattan if your children/spouse are in California? If asked by medical students, I will usually mention that they need to consider location seriously.

Insider/Intimate Knowledge of a Program (4 Points)

As a medical student, it helps to rotate through the radiology residency program you may want to attend. Suppose you know the residents and attendings before starting a program. In that case, you already know the residency program’s upsides and downsides and where “the skeletons are hidden.” Knowledge can be worth its weight in gold. It can be challenging to tell what the true nature of a residency program is like before starting a program. Therefore, having insider knowledge can help you when you begin your residency because “you know what you are getting into.” These residents often are some of the most successful because they have a distinct advantage of knowing the attendings, residents, and the hospital system, even before beginning their residency. Do not dismiss insider knowledge as a factor for making this big decision.

Rotations/Equipment/Procedure Volumes (4 points)

I am lumping these factors into one conglomerate. Why? Naturally, the residency must have all the resources you will need to be comfortable with to practice radiology. If you are in a program where the diversity of patients and patient volumes are sorely lacking, you will be at a loss when you are out in practice and have not seen those cases in your area of practice. Likewise, if the faculty does not perform procedures such as arthrograms or your program doesn’t have a 64 or 256 multidetector CT scanner for the interpretation of cardiac CTAs, you will certainly not feel comfortable performing these procedures when you are an attending.

So, you must make sure to search for a program that has all the necessary resources to allow you to learn all the imaging and procedure skills you will need to become a competent radiologist. Furthermore, as summarized in another post, Best Radiology Electives for the Senior Resident, it is imperative that you can rotate in areas of weakness or interest during your residency. Why? Because hiring practices are looking for residents who can do a subspecialty and are competent in most areas of general radiology practice. So when you are in interviews or looking up information on the web, make sure to look into these factors. Once you have started a residency program without all the crucial resources to make a great radiology resident, there is no going back!!!

Community vs. University Programs (3 points)

Incoming medical students tend to put more weight on attending a “university program” rather than a “community” program. However, both programs give distinct advantages that applicants do not realize before choosing a residency program. A sizeable academic university program does not fit everyone’s career path. So, what are the advantages and disadvantages of each?

Depth Of Resources

Large academic university programs tend to have resources in specific subspecialties and have several attendings that practice in a particular subspecialty. On the other hand, the smaller community programs tend to have more general radiologists that cross cover multiple specialty areas. So, as a resident attending a university program, you will get a more in-depth experience focusing on individual subspecialties. As a community program resident, you will get a more private practice and “real world” hands-on experience. So these programs should attract different types of radiology residents.

Beauracracy

Also, at community programs, you tend to have more accessibility to your attendings and will more likely work one-on-one with that individual. Also, if you have a specific need, it is more likely to be addressed personally without having to go through “bureaucracy” to get there.

At a sizeable university program, more physicians will intercede with direct attending teachings such as senior residents, visiting fellows, fellows, and junior attendings. You may also need to get through bureaucracies to obtain specific resources within your program. However, some electives and rotations may not be available in a smaller community program, such as connections for abroad electives or other opportunities.

Summary

So, this factor should play a role in your decision. But, it depends on the type of practice you want when you leave the system. One is not better than the other for all.

Private vs. Academic Run Departments (3 points)

This factor is often not mentioned or included as a factor in making a residency program decision. But having worked at private, hybrid, and academic programs, I think it should be essential.

I completed my residency in the private/academic hybrid model, and I found some real advantages to this sort of residency program. We had to get through a specific number of cases each day to meet the appropriate caseload. It was a more “real world” experience that allowed me to hit the ground running when I started my first job. I was dictating loads of cases from the beginning and had tons of experience by the time I graduated. My experience was very different from some of my more academic-run department-trained colleagues that I knew. Some of them had more difficulty getting through lots of cases during the day and felt a bit more uncomfortable at their first community radiology job. It made a difference in the long run for me, as it allowed me to become a more efficient general radiologist.

Academic run departments with attendings hired by the hospital emphasize different qualities. These departments may have more resources dedicated to teaching daily. For the resident interest in a purely academic job, it may be heaven!!! But, they may not simulate the real world. They can perseverate on a few cases for an extended period. So, for the radiology resident interested in private practice, a residency such as this may not be the right fit.

Conferences (3 points)

The ACGME theoretically requires all residencies to have at least a daily conference. But, not all are created equal. Some programs have additional morning conferences, while others have the resident prepare for and present at interdisciplinary conferences. And, even others have residents prepare medical student teaching conferences. The styles and types of meetings can vary widely at each program.

Additionally, you should ask if the attendings regularly show up to give their conferences. Please beware of the program with many on paper, but in reality, it does not have the number they suggest.

The importance of the number and type of conference depends on the individual resident. Some residents learn better with didactic sessions, and others benefit from hands-on direct radiology experience. So, the importance of this factor will vary with the individual applying.

Graduating Resident Fellowships (3 points)

It is critical to check where the former residents have gone to fellowships. Are the residents not able to get into competitive subspecialties? Are they going to “no-name” programs? Do the attendings at the institution have connections and networks with other fellowship programs throughout the country? These are questions that you should ask when you get to your residency interview. Or, you should check online for this information. Knowing where prior residents have attended can show you if they get into competitive subspecialties and fellowships.

Research (2 points)

For the academically oriented, research can be an essential factor in selecting a radiology residency. For the community-oriented, it is less so. But, when you look for jobs, having done some research implies an interest in and commitment to radiology. So, it is essential to have had some experience on your resume to get both the academic and private practice job. Therefore, research within an institution should play some role in your decision.

To make this assessment, it helps to get a list of the resident research output over the past five years. You can see what kinds of studies the current residents have completed. Are there retrospective studies, case reports, or large prospective trials? Is each resident finishing lots of projects? And, does the program have research conferences to support the resident? These findings should help you decide if the residency has a curriculum that encourages residency research.

Mentorship Programs (2 points)

Some residency programs have a dedicated teaching program that helps out first-year residents and gives didactic lectures. Others assign an attending mentor to the resident that is the “go to” person for all issues during their four years of residency. When added to the other factors, applicants can use these perks to help make a final decision.

Board Passage Rates (1 point)

I will include board pass rates last because I believe that studying for the new core exam is more of an individual’s responsibility. Of course, you need to pass your boards. But, I think that the overall residency experience becomes more critical in making you into a great radiologist than the board passage statistics. On the other hand, a radiology residency program should have primary resources for residents to pass the exam. They should have learning materials and books as well as board reviews. Great residencies have had lower board pass rates, large academic institutions, and small programs over the past few years. In the end, the examination is very different from the practice of radiology, but it is another hurdle to overcome.

Putting It All Together

No one factor should make or break your decision to go to a specific program. But instead, the different factors should be weighed based on the individual applicant’s needs and wants. So, add up the numerical point totals for each program next to each section and develop a final score to create a final rank list for every residency program.

To summarize, though, for most residents, I sincerely believe that you need to take the residency culture to be one of the most critical conditions for ranking a program in the residency match. And, location can have a significant effect on your happiness or misery during those four years. But, a quality residency culture and a suitable place without adequate training resources would not be enough. So, be careful when you factor each into consideration.

A great radiologist is the sum of one’s experiences that often stems from radiology residency as the initial building block. Ensure that the foundation will provide you with the training you need to become the best you can be. It can be a difficult choice, but I hope I have provided you with the tools you need to make that decision. Good luck with the match!!!

Posted on by — 2 Comments

Can You Pass The Real Saint Barnabas Diagnostic Residency Precall Quiz?

Today you are in for a treat. Our first-year residents at Saint Barnabas have all passed my homemade Precall Quiz with flying colors. So I was thinking why not publish the same 10 cases with images/videos below so you can test yourselves? (Don’t forget to look at the links to the videos for questions 2,3,5,6,8, and 10 that are either after the images or are on their own!) I also gave each resident up to 5 minutes to come up with a final diagnosis and they had to get at least 80% correct to pass. Can you do the same? Check out the answers at the bottom of this page to see h0w you did. If you pass, you are ready to take call!!! Let’s begin!!!

One…

 

Two…

 

Case 2 movie

 

Three…

 

 

Case 3 movie

 

Four…

 

 

Five…

 

Case 5 movie

 

Six…

 

Case 6 movie

 

Seven…

 

 

Eight…

 

Case 8 movie

 

Nine..

 

April 4, 2016

 

 

April 4, 2015

 

 

April 4. 2015

 

Ten…

 

Case 10 movie

 

1. Free air and air tracking adjacent to the ascending colon.

2. Acute appendicitis

3. Type A Aortic Dissection- Call Vascular Surgery!!!

4. T10-11 Disc Herniation with acute cord compression and possible early cord edema.

5. Normal/ nonspecific mesenteric subcentimeter nodes- ? mesenteric adenitis

6. Right-sided UVJ stone with right-sided hydroureter and hydronephrosis.

7. Left MCA distribution acute infarct with MCA thrombus. Evolving right frontal infarct.

8. Bilateral pulmonary emboli and right pleural effusion/air space disease

9. Probable old trochanteric avulsion fracture- Key point- it is chronic (lesson- look at priors!!!)

10. Proximal sigmoid mass, probably subserosal with findings suggestive of large bowel obstruction. Additional mesenteric adenopathy.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Posted on by

How To Artfully Communicate Uncertainty

uncertainty

Many of you know the oldest radiology joke in the book: What is the national plant of radiology? The Hedge! In truth, we as radiologists have to face more uncertainty in our profession than most. Diagnoses of 100 percent certainty are rare. And, we need to communicate this information to our fellow clinicians reasonably. So, how do radiologists do this without infuriating our clinical colleagues? To investigate how, I will divide this post into multiple sections, each one with a meaningful discussion to help you decrease uncertainty for the clinician. Welcome to my world!!!

Don’t Beat Around The Bush

Say what you mean and mean what you say. Don’t hem and haw about your insecurities. Even though we cannot come up with a final diagnosis at times, it is important to say just that. Make sure not to put in too many caveats and extra words. If you see a liver lesion and it could be an atypical hemangioma or hypervascular metastases, don’t use flowery language or multiple qualifiers like the words: however, compelling, of course, and so on. Just say the differential diagnosis includes hemangioma or hypervascular metastasis.

Excommunicate Cannot Be Excluded

One of my most hated phrases in radiology is (drum roll please…) “cannot be excluded.” But, it is not just my least favorite phrase; it is also the clinicians’. Why? It has the potential to force a clinician to investigate further an unlikely diagnosis. 

If you think that a renal lesion is most likely a hemorrhagic cyst, you should say the renal lesion is most likely a hemorrhagic cyst. Suppose the possibility of a renal cell carcinoma is slight. In that case, you can say that the features are not characteristic for a renal cell carcinoma and the likelihood of the lesion to be a renal cell carcinoma is exceedingly rare. On the other hand, if you use the term renal cell carcinoma cannot be excluded; you give the clinician no sense of the actual probability of renal cell carcinoma. The phrase cannot be excluded often causes the unintended consequence of additional unnecessary workups related to your dictation.

Correlate Clinically

Another way to reduce uncertainty is to find additional clinical information on the patient. If you are not sure, look up the laboratories, the prior studies, the actual clinical history, the vital signs, or the accurate ER report to add more certainty to your report. Think of it this way. You have one report that says: chest film shows right lower lobe pulmonary parenchyma disease, possibly pneumonia, atelectasis, or pulmonary edema. On the other hand, you have another report stating the following: Given the elevated white count of 20 and the patient’s elevated temperature of 106 degrees, the right lower lobe pulmonary parenchymal air space disease is most likely pneumonia. You can see that the increased certainty of diagnosis in the second report is significantly more helpful to the clinician that ordered the study.

Specify Probabilities

If you are not sure of the diagnosis, why not just say the probability of the diagnosis? At least, this will help the physician on the other end of the report know how far to work up the patient for other possibilities. Giving a laundry list of diagnoses x versus y versus z helps no one. But, if you know the chance of x is much greater than y, which is greater than z, that opens up a whole new way for the clinician to proceed next with the patient.

Describe The Findings Well

Finally, if you are unsure of the final disposition, make sure you describe the findings well. For instance, if you see bulky adenopathy in the right hilum, make sure to say the size and shape, whether it narrows the mainstem bronchus, and if it causes post-obstructive atelectasis or pneumonia. You may not know the diagnosis. But, the clinician can now decide whether they can get to the abnormal lymph node by bronchoscopy or proceed to the next step. By describing the findings well, you ensure that the physician will work up the patient appropriately.

Communicating Uncertainty Well!

Our specialty is fraught with uncertainty. That is OK. It’s just the way it is. More importantly, good skills to communicate uncertainty can save your reputation and the reputation of the specialty. Suppose you follow my advice about directly saying what you mean. In that case, avoiding cannot be excluded; looking up clinical information while incorporating it into your report; specifying probabilities, and describing the findings well, you can at least drive the clinical physician to the appropriate next step. See. Uncertainty is not that bad!!! Just like always, it is all about good quality communication.

 

Posted on by

Most Common Stereotypical Generation Radiologist Differences

generation

 

Millennial
Generation X
Baby Boomer

 

 

 

 

 

 

Although not every radiologist fits the particular stereotype for their generation, some generational stereotypes ring true. On the whole, the baby boomers, Generation X, and Millennials perform better and worse in some parts of the radiology workforce and have their own particular needs. When you work with these individuals, it is vital to keep this in mind. Sometimes, we need to change the way we operate to accommodate these differences. So, today I would like to go through some areas where radiologist generations differ, arranged by different topics. I hope you enjoy it!

PACS And Social Media

Baby Boomers: These folks tend to be less comfortable with PACS system changes. So, beware of the PACS upgrade! It can wreak havoc on their lives. Social media can be somewhat foreign to these radiologists. Many of these radiologists do not have Facebook, Linkedin, or Instagram accounts. So, sending out messages via these media may be a waste of your time.

Generation X: For these radiologists, PACS utility issues tend to be a mixed bag. Some of the less tech-savvy radiologists fall into a similar category as a Baby Boomer. Others are more adept with PACS systems. On the other hand, social media outlets are generally much more native to the Generation X radiologist with broader and more frequent use. Although not all of these radiologists use social media, you will be more likely to find these folks more comfortable.

Millennials: On the whole, these radiologists cope well with PACS updates and changes as long as the network runs correctly. Their technology knowledge enables these individuals to learn quickly and grasp the most efficient ways to learn PACS. Social media is not just a tool for many of these individuals; it can be a way of life. Their online persona can become just as important as their offline interactions. They tend to engross themselves in the online world.

Barium Work/General X-rays

Baby Boomers: This group of individuals has, by far, the most expansive repertoire of experiences with both barium work and plain films. Since it was the mainstay of radiology initially, they often pick things up that their more junior colleagues will miss. They can work wonders with barium and grasp the nuances of a good barium examination.

Generation X: They can read plain films rather adeptly and efficiently. Although not as seasoned as a Baby Boomer, they can read an x-ray reasonably well and are comfortable with most barium work. During residency, they have had lots of experience with films and barium slinging.

Millennials: Since they spend a lot more time with CT and MRI than plain film work during the residency, overall, they are less comfortable with plain film interpretation. As residents, hardcore barium studies experience such as barium enemas can be minimal. So, the performance and interpretation of these studies can be a bit more challenging.

MRI

Baby Boomers: It is much less likely for the Baby Boomer to feel comfortable in this modality since they may have completed MRI training after their residency. Most Baby Boomers will avoid MRI if possible.

Generation X: Plus or minus. Depending on the experiences during residency, some feel very comfortable with general MRI work and others less so.

Millennials: Most Millenials are comfortable with all MRI since it has become “bread and butter” radiology, just as standard as all the other modalities out there. I would certainly put a lot of faith in their excellent reads!

Vacation Time

Baby Boomers: This generation believes in the adage “live to work.” Overall, they tend to take less vacation than given (although they get more vacation time than the rest of the generations!)

Generation X: They have a similar work ethic to the Baby Boomers than Millenials, although they can straddle both sides. Vacation time is essential, and they fully take advantage of their time off the job.

Millennials: Everyone needs to work around the Millennials’ schedule. Their motto is “work to live, not live to work.” They like flexibility in their schedule and will do whatever they can to get to the lifestyle they want. Every day a practice gives vacation time, these radiologists will take the day. They do not spare a moment that they can use to bolster their lifestyle.

Money

Baby Boomers: For the most part, these radiologists sit on a large nest egg, having worked through radiology during its most lucrative years. Debt load tends to be nonexistent. They have the most flexibility and can leave the workforce whenever they want. Many of these radiologists perform their job solely for the “love.”

Generation X: Most of these radiologists have paid off their debts and have done relatively well in their specialty. Money is still important to these folks because they still do not have enough to retire. But, they have good jobs and will do well overall since they have been working during the “good years.”

Millennials: Severe student debt weighs down these radiologists and can limit their opportunities to places and jobs that this generation does not want. It almost runs counter to their ideal lifestyle philosophy. These radiologists also started to work in the field during lean radiology years and are more likely to have had less opportunity to make money. Hence, there is some bitterness when it comes to discussing the topic of money!

Interpersonal Relationships

Baby Boomers: Overall, this group develops solid interpersonal relationships with their colleagues and staff. They never had the opportunity to rely on social media or other forms of technological communication, so they deal well with others. In addition, they have the least need for external approval.

Generation X: These radiologists probably have more in common with the Baby Boomers than the Millenials since they grew up in a world without social media. They were allowed to fail just like the Baby Boomers but were more protected than them. But, they do develop strong interpersonal relationships with their colleagues.

Millennials: Since many of these folks were not allowed to fail growing up, they need to be outwardly appreciated by their colleagues much more than the other generation. They spend a lot of time on their mobile devices, garnering relationships with others. Since online life can be just as important as their offline persona, some can seem outwardly unfriendly because of the time they spend on their devices.

Teaching Expectations:

Baby Boomers: They love a great lecturer and taking cases. However, after completing a teaching episode, the Baby Boomer will research and read the topic to reinforce learning. Overall, the Baby Boomer does not care about electronic media, but some will use it. Old-fashioned books instead of ebooks work better for the Baby Boomer.

Generation X: The typical generation Xer fits somewhere between the Baby Boomer and the Millenial. They will do their research and not expect the lecturer to tell them everything they need to know but understand the practicalities of ebooks and electronic resources.

Millennials: They traditionally have been spoon-fed information in lectures. And, they expect everything to be spelled out for them when others teach them. Overall, they expect the teacher to know everything about a topic and point them toward all the resources they need to read. Most Millennials use ebooks exclusively and will utilize electronic media to reinforce all learning.

Summary

I repeat, “These stereotypes certainly do not apply to all radiologists out there!” However, I think there is an overall tendency for individuals of each generation to fit some of the stereotypes. Knowing the strengths and weaknesses of each generation allows us to schedule accordingly, allocate appropriate resources, and understand what each generation needs. For instance, since the Millennial tends to have a higher debt load, allow for more moonlighting opportunities or extra work. Or, make sure to incorporate additional training with new electronic PACS system upgrades for the Baby Boomer. Bottom line- it pays to understand each generation!!!

 

Featured on Aunt Minnie.com!!! Click here for the Aunt Minnie version.

 

 

Posted on by

Ten Of The Most Frustrating Radiologist Phone Calls

phone calls

As radiologists, we speak with ornery physicians, upset patients, uninformed technologists, and headstrong nurses on the phone. Daily, the phone calls we take are not all peaches and cream. Sometimes these phone calls can get the best of us. So, I thought this would be an educational opportunity for those just beginning their residency or considering a career as a radiologist to understand what goes on in daily practice. Here is a list of some of the most distasteful and frustrating phone calls you may encounter when working as a radiologist. It’s part of our life. Expect the worst but hope for the best!!!

Missing The Diagnosis

You’ve been going through films and feel like you are accomplishing significant work today. For the 3rd time today, you hear the phone ring loudly. As you pick up this phone call after a decent day… WHAM… everything changes, your heart sinks. That patient with pancreatitis has pyelonephritis, and you can hear the physician’s upset but pleasant tone. Can things get worse?

Any Call For Barium Study After 12 AM

Your eyes are watery, and you are barely staying awake in the reading room. Suddenly, the phone rings. “We need a barium swallow to look for a stuck chicken bone in my patient’s throat.” Now I’m never going to get any shuteye. Ugh, the pain won’t stop!

Bad Timing

You have a patient with unsuspected metastases on a thoracic spine MRI, and you attempt to reach out to the physician who ordered the study. “Hi. Is this Dr.______?” Next thing you know, he starts yelling at you, “How dare you to call me while I am at my father’s funeral!!!” He bluntly hangs up the phone. So much for good physician communication!

Contrast Stupidity

You arrive at your workstation and receive a requisition for an abdomen and pelvic CT scan with contrast for a patient with symptoms of flank pain and urinary tract stones. So, you call up the physician and tell her, “I think that you made a mistake with the order. You meant without contrast, right?” The next thing you know, she is arguing with you how contrast studies are better for patients to diagnose an obstructive stone. The conversation goes on for what seems like hours. It’s like talking to a piece of cheese. Oh, My God!!!!

Fellow Physician With Positive Findings

A physician friend comes down from his department and asks you to give him a call when you get a chance to look at his chest x-ray. He has a mild cough. So you oblige and say, “OK.” Ten minutes later… You look at his film, and he has sclerotic bone lesions and pulmonary nodules everywhere. Looks like mets. Gulp. You pick up the phone, not quite sure what to say. Finally, your voice cracks, “Can you come down here. I need to speak to you in person.” Poor guy. How am I going to break the news to him?

Misplaced Anger

As part of your typical protocol, you call in the results of a normal V/Q scan. Suddenly you hear a booming voice on the other end, “HOW DARE YOU CALL ME FOR A NORMAL STUDY DURING REGULAR BUSINESS HOURS!!!!!!!!” You hear a loud click. So much for congeniality…

Demand For Incorrect Protocols

You are going through a knee MRI and notice that the tech did not include the coronal images even though they are essential to evaluate the collateral ligaments. So, you call the technologist to determine why the MRI does not include the appropriate imaging after the patient recently had a motor vehicle accident. The technologist says smugly, “Oh, we didn’t need these images because the clinician said they don’t need the coronal images.” What?

Clinicians That Expect You To Make Their Clinical Decisions

On the queue, a film pops up, and you look at the images. At the left base, overlying the cardiac silhouette, there is an airspace opacity obscuring the diaphragm. So, you decide to call the Emergency Department, and you get through to the Nurse Practitioner. You tell her, “The patient has a left lower lobe pneumonia.” Surprisingly, she asks you, “How do I treat this patient? What kind of antibiotics should I administer?” Listen, buddy- this is above my pay grade. That’s your job!!!

Request For Stats But No One Is Home

At the outpatient center, you see an abdominal and pelvic CT scan with a prescription that says STAT, needs a prompt phone call to the doctor. So, you look at the study at 4 PM and find mild diverticulitis of the sigmoid colon. So, you call the number and receive a message prompt; please dial _______ number to get through to the doctor. Next, you call the number and talk to the secretary. She casually says, “The doctor is not around and there is no one covering.” But, you respond, “But it says STAT!”. She then retorts, “But no one his here.” The phone hangs up abruptly with deafening silence…

The Need To Call The Patient Directly

The patient has abdominal free air on a random CT scan of the chest for pneumonia. So, you call the clinician for the 3rd time after leaving multiple messages with the answering service. No response. The only next available option is to contact the patient directly to come into the emergency room to get checked out. So, you find the number and speak to the husband of the patient, who is 90 years old. He says, “What are you talking about? You need to call my doctor. I don’t understand why my wife has to go to the emergency room.” You spend about 45 minutes on the phone trying to convince him to get her wife to the hospital because you can’t get through to the doctor. Finally, you get the husband to take her wife to the emergency room. Fifteen minutes later, after this long-winded conversation, you get a phone call from the patient’s doctor. What a waste of time!

Phone Calls Can Be Painful!

Although many phone calls are positive and rewarding, these are just some of the phone calls that will frustrate you as a radiologist. So be prepared to have some pretty painful phone conversations with your fellow clinicians, colleagues, and friends. It’s part of the job!!!

 

 

 

 

Posted on by

USMLE Step III- An Impediment For Radiologists?

Over the past few years, we have been witnessing a new phenomenon that I don’t think is unique to our diagnostic radiology residency program. Incoming residents are either delaying or failing their USMLE Step III examinations. Some of this new reality may be related to the decreased competitiveness of radiology. However, what is interesting is that some of the residents that fail or delay the examination are not toward the bottom of their respective classes but rather are high performing residents with a good fund of background knowledge in radiology. That got me thinking. What is going on with the new USMLE Step III examination? And, should the examination be a prequalifying factor for obtaining medical licensure prior to becoming a radiologist?

According to the USMLE Step III website, “Step 3 content reflects a data-based model of generalist medical practice in the United States. The test items and cases reflect the clinical situations that a general, as-yet undifferentiated, physician might encounter within the context of a specific setting. Step 3 provides a final assessment of physicians assuming independent responsibility for delivering general medical care.”

If you actually take apart the content of this summary statement of the Step III boards, you will see that the goal of the examination is in no way applicable to the intellectual goals/medical knowledge necessary for being a good radiologist. Based on the responses of many of my residents that have already taken the test, the questions, and content of the test have limited applicability to the practice of radiology. Very few questions are radiology related and have clinical scenarios that would ever be useful background information for a radiology resident/radiologist. So, is it really warranted to have radiology residents pass such an exam in order to practice their specialty? What is its utility?

Furthermore, the concept of having an intern that trains for one year and practices independent medicine is outdated, to say the least. Almost no hospital or clinic would ever hire a physician without some sort of complete residency training in a specialty whether it be internal medicine, psychiatry, or radiation oncology, let alone radiology. The liability of a hiring physician without this training would be enormous. I, for one, would never let any of my family members see a physician with one year of internship training who had merely passed the Step III USMLE examination.

More relevant to us, radiologists and other subspecialists never practice independent general medical care. The clinical situations that undifferentiated physicians encounter is very different from the needs of subspecialist radiologists. So, why prepare a physician for an end goal that he or she is never going to realize?

All these issues, bring me to this final conclusion. Maybe we consider creating a new examination that is actually going to be relevant to the goals of the subspecialist and not the general practitioner. Perhaps, we should create two separate exams, one with a general pathway and the other with the subspecialty pathway in mind. At least, you would create a test with increased relevancy and with a practical end goal for the individual subspecialist that would help with their future career requirements.

It is time to rethink the requirements for resident physicians obtaining medical licensure since the present concept of practicing independent care as a physician after one year is outdated and dangerous. And, subspecialists have different needs from general practitioners. With that, the Step III examination should change accordingly.